Jacob Sider Jost is a professor of English at Dickinson College.

Sider Jost, Jacob. Hume's Four Philosophers: Recasting theTreatise of Human Nature .'" Modern Intellectual History 6, no. 1 (2009): 1-25. https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/modern-intellectual-history/article/humes-four-philosophers-recasting-the-treatise-of-human-nature/354E59D093F2FAB2EB66B776E5D00AEF

For more information on the published version, visit Cambridge University Press's Website. https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/modern-intellectual-history/article/humes-four-philosophers-recasting-the-treatise-of-human-nature/354E59D093F2FAB2EB66B776E5D00AEF
© 2009 by Cambridge University Press. All rights reserved

Disappointed by the indifferent reception of his 1739 'Treatise of Human Nature', particularly in view of his commitment to vividness and convincingness as epistemological criteria, Hume recast crucial arguments from his 'Treatise' in The Epicurean, The Stoic, The Platonist, and The Sceptic, four pieces from his 1741-2 Essays Moral and Political. Locating these texts within both the dialogue and essay genres, I demonstrate how Hume continues the project of the Treatise by showing, rather than telling, his views: he blends rhetoric and reasoned argument to show that they are in many cases indistinguishable; he depicts his speakers' conclusions as consequences of their personalities to show his skepticism about human freedom; and he concludes, in a moment strongly reminiscent of the famous end of book I of the Treatise, by showing the limits of philosophy itself.

Citation